• English
  • 简体中文
  • 繁體中文
  • Tiếng Việt
  • ไทย
  • Indonesia
Subscribe

What is the Fisher Effect, and why does it still Work?

Saqib Iqbal

Nov 22, 2021 15:03

截屏2021-11-22 下午3.06.08.png


The actual importance and value of the fisher effect are evident in its wide use happening in economics and the monetary sector. This concept is widely used to display the relationship between inflation as well as both real and the nominal interest rate.


For some people, it is a completely new term, and the equation calculation often confuses them for a second to achieve desired results. But there is no need to panic because we have a quick discussion about the Fisher effect and its difference from the International Fisher Effect.

What is the fisher effect?

As we define the fisher effect, it is a concept in economics that defines the relationship between real interest rates and nominal rates under the inflation effect. According to the Fisher Effect equation, the nominal interest rate equals the total real interest rate plus inflation.


The Fisher equation is very common in such situations where lenders and investors ask for additional rewards for compensation for their losses.


The Fisher Effect concept is generally used in economics and finance fields. You can also use it to calculate the investment returns or predict the behavior of real and nominal interest rates.


An interesting finding of the Fisher equation is in terms of monetary policy. This equation believes that the monetary policy moves the inflation and nominal interest rates together in the same direction. But the monetary policy does not display any effect on the real interest rate.


The Fisher Effect equation was proposed by famous American economist Irving Fisher.

Fisher equation formula

The Fisher equation is generally expressed through the below-mentioned formula:

(1 + i)  = (1 + r) (1 + π)


Where:

  • i – is the nominal interest rate

  • r – is the real interest rate

  • π –is the inflation rate


If not this, then you can even utilize the approximate version of its previous formula, which is:

I ≈ r + π


The Fisher effect formula is based on the one-year, generally broken down into three main components. It includes a nominal interest rate, the real rate of interest, and the expected inflation rate.


A nominal interest rate is a form of percentage which displays the price you have to pay for using money without taking the inflation into your account.


Whereas the real interest rate is the small percentage adjusted just to remove inflation effects and measure the real purchasing power.


Expect inflation rate is the percentage that changes based on current economic cycles.

Nominal interest rates & real interest rates

A financial return is generally reflected through the nominal interest rates an individual is getting on the deposited money.


For instance, 10$ per year nominal interest rate means that the person will be receiving an extra 10% from their deposited money in the bank.


Unlike any nominal interest rate, the real interest rate even considers the purchasing power in that equation.


If we talk about the Fisher Effect concept, the nominal interest rate is the actual interest rate. It reflects the monetary growth padded with time to a specific currency or money owed by a financial lender.


The real interest rate is the amount that displays the purchasing power of borrowed money as it starts to grow with time.

Importance of the Fisher effect in money supply

The Fisher effect is not just an equation; it is far more than that! It highlights how money supply will affect the overall nominal interest rate and the inflation rate as a tandem.


For instance, if the change in the central bank's monetary policy will push the country's inflation rate to 10 percentage points, then similarly, the nominal interest rate of that economy will also increase by 10 percentage points.


Hence, any change in money supply will never affect the rate of real interest. But it will directly reflect the changes happening within the nominal interest rate.

Short-term applications of fisher effect

The Fisher Effect is based on short-term practical applications which you can utilize in your everyday life. This whole concept is basically about estimating the purchasing power according to inflation rates. Therefore, you can use it even for defining the real rate of return on any investment to see what profits you can buy.


For instance, if you purchase a 1 year certificate of deposit for at least $5,000 towards an interest rate of around 0.94 percent and still the inflation stays constant, you can expect to make $5,047.22 at the end year.

What is the long-term significance of the fisher effect?

We all know that a real rate of interest is necessary for making certain great investment decisions. Therefore, using the Fisher effect for calculating the short-term effects can be useful and, at the same time, interesting to acquire significant results during the long term.  


The compound calculation is the major tool to analyze the investment potential to predict the initial investment amount and nominal interest rate. It even informs you about in what economic cycle you should start selling.

What are the three major fishers that affect applications?

We all know that Fisher is basically about describing the relationship between nominal interest rate and real interest rate. But it is generally divided into three major disciplines, which are:

1. Monetary Policy

Central banks use this economic theory to control inflation and often maintain it within a healthy range.

Every central bank of a country makes sure that there is slight inflation to avoid a deflator spiral. This is because too much inflation can also overheat the entire economic channel.


Central banks set nominal interest rates by changing the reserve ratio to prevent inflation from deflation or spiraling upward. They are also making some open market operations for achieving better results.

2. Portfolio Returns

For assessing the portfolio and the investment returns, you should understand the basic nuances between real interest and nominal interest. This is how you can identify the true returns which are offered by any investment with time.


It might be a happy moment for you if you avail 10% of nominal interest on your invested money. But during that period, if there is 15% of inflation, you will realize that you have lost 5% of the purchasing power.


Therefore, the Fisher equation is used to determine the accurate nominal interest rate of the return, which investment needs to ensure that the investor generates the "real" return with time.

3. Currency Markets

In currency markets, the Fisher Effect is known as the International Fisher Effect. With this economic concept, an individual can predict the instant spot exchange rate of the currency which belongs to different countries. And this will be done in the light of differences related to the country's nominal interest rates.


Future spot rate can be calculated based on a nominal interest rate of two various countries and spot exchange rate within the market during that day.

The pros and cons of the fisher effect

Pros

A few major advantages/uses of the fisher effect are:

  • It is closely linked with macroeconomics. Hence, it highlights the causal relationship between inflation and interest rate. According to the Fisher effect, an increase in the nominal rates can cause a decrease in inflation.

  • In the currency markets, the Fisher Effect is known as the International Fisher Effect. This IFE concept showcases the relationship between nominal interest rates of two different countries. It even identifies the exchange rate for their respective currencies.

Cons

Now let's talk about a few of the major cons/disadvantages of the fisher effect to make the reader understand it more:

  • Nominal interest rates are not considered to be the only determinant of the nominal exchange rates. Hence, the international trade that determines the exchange rates is not just operated through price but through quality. This will often affect the inflation differences between two dissimilar countries. Above all, different countries control their exchange rates to protect the domestic economy and boost exports.

  • Secondly, the capital does not flow freely. According to Fisher's assumption, capital can flow freely between different countries, which leads to equal real interest rates worldwide. Just because the real interest rates have been equal, the nominal interest rates will gradually equal the difference within the expected inflation of each country. However, some countries have restrictions on the flow of capital. Legal barriers and transaction costs are a few factors that cause the interest rates to differ among countries.

  • Exchange rates gradually work not just through international trade but even through capital flows. Once the domestic interest rate goes higher, foreign investors enter, which increases the demand for domestic currency and hence causes appreciation.

What are the limitations of the fisher effect?

One major limitation of the Fisher Effect is due to the elasticity of demand regarding the interest rates. In the condition of high consumer confidence and rising asset prices, a certain high real interest rate might not be having a meaningful effect on reducing demand.


Another major limitation is associated with the liquidity traps. It can occur when saving rates are extremely high, and interest rates are a bit low.


Within the liquidity trap, reducing nominal interest rates will have no impact on increasing consumer spending. This is because lower interest rates never encourage investment or spending.

What is the international fisher effect?

Discussing, the International Fisher Effect displays the changes happening within exchange rates of two different currencies. These currencies have to correlate with the differences in the nominal interest rates between two different countries.


IFE, International Fisher Effect, is the term named after the famous American economist and the developer of the Fisher Effect, Irving Fisher.


Hypothesis plays a major role in predicting the entire movement of spot currency and future spot prices.

In short, if the domestic nominal interest rate is gradually higher than the rate within the trading partner, you can expect depreciation in the domestic currency exchange rate against the currency of the partner's country.


According to Fisher, interest rates will always provide a stronger indication to highlight the performance of a country's currency. When keeping in view the relationship between nominal interest rates and the changes in the exchange rates, you hold numerous assumptions, which are:

  • Capital is freely flowing between different countries

  • Real interest rates turn out to be equal between different countries worldwide

  • Capital markets are somewhere internationally integrated

  • No controls over currency

The difference between the fisher effect and the international fisher effect

The Fisher Effect is about describing the relationship between the rate of inflation and interest rates. According to them, the nominal interest rate of a country is equal to the real interest rate plus the inflation rate. This gradually means that the real interest rate equals the nominal interest rate minus the inflation rate.


In this way, any increase within the inflation rate will also result in a proportional increase within the nominal interest rate. But in this whole situation, the real interest rate will stay constant.


For instance, if the assumed real interest rate is 5.5%, then the inflation rate will change from 2.5% to 3.5%. Nominal interest rate is generally calculated as:

(1 + Nominal Interest Rate) = (1+Real Interest Rate) (1+Inflation Rate)

Nominal Interest Rate = (1+0.055) (1+0.025) – 1

= (1.055) (1.025) – 1

= 0.081 or 8.1%

Nominal Interest Rate = (1.055) (1.035) – 1

= 0.092 or 9.2%


Hence, the nominal interest rate will gradually increase from 8.1% when the inflation rate is 2.5%. And it needs to increase at 9.2% as soon as the inflation rate increases to 3.5%.


The International Fisher Effect is the expanded version of the Fisher Effect. IFE suggests that the estimated depreciation or appreciation of the currencies of two different countries is proportional to the instant difference in their overall nominal interest rates.


For instance, if the nominal interest rate in the US is greater than the UK, then the value of the former currency will gradually fall due to emerging differences in the interest rate.

Does the international fisher effect work?

Irving Fisher designed the international fisher effect approach to build a pure model of interest rates and make it look like the leading indicator.


It is capable enough to predict the movement of future currency for almost 1 whole year. But the major drawback of the international fisher effect model is its uncovered interest parity. This means that you won't identify the spot prices and will know the exact interest rate.


Before introducing the International Fisher Effect, most companies were controlling their exchange rates because of certain trade and economic purposes.


But now, the currencies are free-floating, which brings some questions over the significance of the International Fisher effect. So when we talk about purchasing power parity, IFE has been a complete failure. And hence this is the major drawback of theory.


Purchasing power parity, also known as PPP, is a theory in economics that compares the currencies of two different economies with the help of common goods.

Frequently asked questions- FAQs

1. What is the main purpose of the Fisher effect?

Defining the term Fisher Effect is an economic theory introduced by famous economist Irving Fisher. Its main purpose is to describe the relationship between inflation and both nominal and real interest rates. Real interest rates will always fall when inflation increases which often increases the nominal interest rates.

2. What is the Fisher equation used for?

The Fisher Effect equation states that the nominal interest rate is equal to the sum of the real interest rate plus inflation. This equation can also be used when an investor or the lender asks for an additional reward for compensating the losses in purchasing power due to certain high inflation.

3. How can you test the International Fisher Effect?

To test the IFE direction, each country is used as the home country and a foreign country. In this way, you can investigate if the International Fisher Effect is either unidirectional or not. Next, each regression coefficient is compared to the hypothesized value and divided by the standard error.

4. How can a Fisher effect impact the market interest rate?

According to the Fisher Effect, the real interest rate equals the nominal interest rate minus the expected inflation rate. Therefore, there will be a fall in real interest rates once inflation starts to increase.

Bottom line

To end with the whole discussion, it is clear enough that the Fisher Effect demonstrates the actual relationship between nominal interest rates, real interest rates, and inflation rates.


According to the Fisher Effect, the real interest rate equals the nominal interest rate minus the expected inflation rate. Therefore, there will be a fall in real interest rates once inflation starts to increase.


Similarly, if the inflation rate increases, the real interest rate will go down. But this generally happens when the nominal rates are not increasing at such rates equal to the inflation rates. This effect will always appear over time and not immediately in the shape of a consistent economic pattern.